A gent called me a few months ago. He’d been selling online since the early eighties, one of the first people to do it, long before anyone called it internet selling. He’d since tried Amazon. Tried Facebook. Tried LinkedIn. Failed on all three. He wanted to know what he’d missed.
It took me those same three platforms and a lot of years to see it for myself.
I’ve finally worked out the answer.
It’s not the people with the best offer who get paid. It’s not the people who post the most. It’s two groups, and only two. People who showed up already trusted by someone. And people teaching other people how to make money on the platform.
Everyone else is invisible, no matter how good the work is. I learned this the hard way, years apart, on three different platforms.
The first time was Amazon.
Before I published my first book, a smart guy told me he’d studied the platform and didn’t believe a writer could make real money there. I didn’t believe him. I put the book up anyway. He was right and wrong at the same time.
I did make money on that book. I just didn’t make it on Amazon. I made it from people who already knew me and bought it because I wrote it, not because Amazon showed it to them. Amazon was where the book lived. It was never where the sale happened.
I’ve watched this play out since with clients, friends, and colleagues who self-publish. They all sell their books. Not on Amazon. Amazon gives them the credibility of being a published author. They sell it on their website, in their emails, inside their own communities, at their keynotes, in collaboration with someone else’s audience. Rarely on Amazon.
The second time was LinkedIn.
For years I couldn’t understand why my results were so spotty. Then I started paying attention to who on that platform was actually making real money, and the pattern was almost embarrassing once I saw it. If you’re on LinkedIn teaching people how to use LinkedIn to make money, you make money. If you’re a person doing your actual work, the only people who buy from you are the people already in your network, the ones who know you. You can build your connections into the thousands. The algorithm will still only show your work to a sliver of them, somewhere between half a percent and three percent, and most of that sliver has no interest in you to begin with.
The third time was watching it happen to someone else.
Substack was built for writers, and for a while, it was lovely. Then Jim Acosta lost his job at CNN and brought his audience with him. A wave of mainstream media journalists who’d been cut followed him, each starting their own channel and bringing readers who already trusted them and were happy to pay to keep hearing from them.
Substack made a fortune, and its own leadership has said so. Right behind that, a small industry sprang up teaching people how to make money on Substack. The people making money there now are the ones who arrived already trusted, the ones who got there first, and the ones selling the how-to underneath it.
Everybody else is writing into a well. I need to be careful about what this means, because it’s easy to hear it as a complaint about algorithms, and it isn’t. It describes what these platforms were actually built to do. None of them were built to sell a stranger your expensive or cheap thing. They were built to hold attention and sell it to advertisers, or, once that stopped paying enough, to sell the promise of holding attention to the next person willing to pay for the lesson.
Whether your book sells or your offer lands was NEVER their business.
That’s not a flaw you can fix with a better hook or a smarter posting schedule. I tested that directly on LinkedIn for six months: the direct ask and the soft one. Same answer both times. Nothing.
That’s what the gent on the phone had missed. Not a tactic. Not a better hook. He’d been early enough, and worked hard enough, that he assumed the platforms owed him something for it. They didn’t. They were never going to sell his thing, no matter how long he’d been at it.
So think about your last real client. Not where they first saw your name. Where did they decide to trust you?
My capacity to ponder outweighs your attention span, so this is the first of three parts on social media. Next up in this series: if the platform was never going to sell the thing, what is it actually for?
